We’ll compare the Spectra S1 and S2 breast pumps’ advantages and disadvantages as well as customer reviews. To find out more, continue reading.
Making a choice between Spectra S1 and S2 is a crucial choice, especially if you’re pumping exclusively or juggling breastfeeding and pumping. Making the pumping session simpler and more convenient will depend on which Spectra breast pump best suits your needs.
Spectra Breast Pump S1 Vs. S2 – Comparison
The hospital-grade breast pumps Spectra 1 and Spectra 2 have many features in common. Before purchasing one of them, however, you should be aware of some differences between them.
The primary distinction between Spectra S1 and Spectra S2 is The difference between the S1 and S2 breast pumps is that the former has a built-in battery, making it more portable. Even without a nearby power outlet, you can still use the Spectra S1 Plus. This feature makes the S1 Spectra pump a little more expensive.
Two additional, minor variations include the fact that the Spectra S2 pump is smaller and pink in color as opposed to the S1 pump’s blue color.
Spectra S1 and S2 Breast Pumps – Similarities
The hospital-grade Spectra S1 Plus and S2 Plus pumps have a massive amount of suction strength (270 mmHg). You can customize each pump’s cycle speed and vacuum to suit your needs.
A pair of 24mm and 28mm flanges are included with both Spectra pumps. I’ve heard that these breast shields ended up being too large for some mothers, who then had to buy smaller ones. The good news is that Spectra sells separate 20mm and 32mm flanges.
The wide-neck Spectra bottles that hold the milk are screwed onto by the flanges and bottle connectors, which are made of one piece.
Single & Double Pumping
You can simultaneously pump both breasts with the Spectra S1 and S2. Being able to express milk simultaneously from both breasts is very practical and obviously faster.
Additionally, you can breastfeed your child on the other breast while only draining one breast.
By the way, research suggests that mom may be able to express nearly 20% more milk with a double pump than with a single pump when switching between pumps. A further benefit of such milk is that it contains more fats, which also increases its calorie and nutritional content.
Closed System & Built-In Backflow Protector
In contrast to many other electric breast pumps, the closed system of the Spectra S1 Plus and Spectra S2 Plus sets them apart. The milk is prevented from backing up into the suction tubes by the built-in backflow protector.
Because it guards against contamination and makes the pumping process more hygienic, this function is crucial because it makes both the mother and the baby safer.
Bacteria, viruses, and mold are kept away from the components of the pump thanks to backflow prevention.
Adjustability – is Spectra S1 Or S2 More Powerful?
The strength of Spectra S2 is equivalent to that of Spectra S1. Massage mode and Expression mode are the two pumping phases shared by the two. The speed in massage mode is 70 cycles per minute. You can adjust the suction strength (from 1 to 5) during this phase but not the speed.
The cycles in the Expression phase can be changed from 38 to 54 CPM, and the vacuum pressure can be altered from 1 to 12. The Spectra S1 Plus and Spectra S2 Plus’s suction strength at level 12 is 270 mmHg, which is very similar to hospital pumps.
What’s notable is that this electric breast pump does not automatically transition from the Massage phase to the Expression phase. You must press the mode button once to start the Expression mode on your own when milk let-down is detected.
With the Spectra S1 Plus and S2 Plus, you can modify the Massage and Expression modes and change between them mid-session.
In conclusion, both Spectra pumps have 12 levels of suction strength (up to 270 mmHg) in the Expression mode and 5 levels of suction in the Massage mode. Only during the Expression phase can the speed be changed.
What’s noteworthy is that Spectra 1’s vacuum may be a little weaker than Spectra 2’s when operating on battery power and when the battery life is low.
Quiet & Long-Life Motor
The Spectra breast pumps’ 45 decibel acoustic output astounded me greatly. Typically, hospital pumps are very noisy, but Spectra is an exception. Although it has a powerful suction, it is not at all loud.
It isn’t completely silent, of course, but it will allow you more freedom of choice than other electric pumps.
The Spectra S1 and S2’s 1500 motor hours of expected life are their best feature. This makes them the longest-lasting breast pumps available.
Because of this remarkable outcome, you will be able to use the Spectra breast pump for more than one child, which makes it an excellent investment.
Night Light
Both the Spectra S2 and S1 breast pumps have an integrated night light. Because of this, using the pump at night is much simpler and more practical.
What is the Difference Between Spectra 1 and Spectra 2?
S1 and S2 pumps differ primarily in two ways: price and built-in battery, as I already mentioned. Additionally, there are two slight variations in both size and color.
Examine the effect these features have on user comfort.
Spectra 1 Vs. 2 – Battery
This is where Spectra breast pumps most significantly diverge. The Spectra S2 lacks a rechargeable battery, whereas the Spectra S1 does.
The S1 model is more portable and convenient as a result of this feature. You do not need to look for a power outlet when it is time for your pumping sessions.
When plugged in and charging, the Spectra S1 can be used. It can also be operated solely on battery power when not connected to an AC outlet.
The Spectra S1 charges in two to three hours. You can pump for 3 hours on a fully charged Spectra S1 battery.
Spectra S2 needs to be plugged into an outlet, unlike the S1 breast pump. Only an AC adapter can power it.
With a rechargeable battery, the Spectra S1 allows for on-the-go pumping while traveling, at work, on the road, or even in an airplane.
Because of all of these factors, the Spectra S1 is a fantastic option for mothers who exclusively pump, are frequently on the go, or have returned to work while still wanting to breastfeed their infant.
When choosing between Spectra S1 vs. Spectra S2: When the battery is running low, I’ve noticed a slight drop in S1 suction. Aside from that, both breast pumps are equally powerful and effective at expressing milk.
Spectra 1 Vs. 2 – Size
The size difference between Spectra S1 and S2 is barely perceptible.
Spectra 1 Vs. 2 – Color
There is also a color difference; while it isn’t a deal-breaker, it should be considered. Breast pumps from Spectra S1 and S2 are both available in blue and pink, respectively.
Spectra 1 Vs. 2 – Price
It costs more than the Spectra S2 breast pump because the Spectra S1 has a rechargeable battery and can operate without an AC adapter.
I believe that the ability to pump anywhere balances out the price difference. The Spectra S1 is definitely worth the extra money if you’re looking for a portable electric breast pump.
Which is Better: Spectra S1 Or S2? – Final Decision
How can you tell which of these two breast pumps will suit you better when they are virtually identical? If you’re debating whether to buy a Spectra S1 or a. S2, just consider these things:
- Will you express milk only at home, or also in other locations like your office at work, a car, an airplane, etc.?
- Do you want a breast pump that doesn’t need an AC adapter?
- Do you mind being “chained” to a power outlet while pumping?
- What is your spending limit, and are you willing to spend a little more to have access to a portable pump and the ability to collect breast milk anywhere?
The Spectra S1 Plus appears to be a better choice if features like portability and a rechargeable battery are important to you. It can be used anywhere, even if there is a power outage or when you are traveling. You’ll have access to pumping facilities at home, at work, in a car, on an airplane, or on a train.
If you must stay within your spending limit and don’t mind pumping only near an electrical outlet, the Spectra S2 will work just fine for you.
What Factors Should You Consider in Choosing a Breast Pump?
Purchasing a breast pump is a big commitment and a little scary, especially if you intend to use it exclusively for pumping. Despite the fact that you’ll be using your pump for two hours a day, you frequently have to purchase it without first trying it out or seeing it in person.
I sat in front of the website for two hours trying to decide which pump to get when I finally received my last one through insurance.
By considering the features that are most significant to you, you can choose the pump that is right for you. Examples might be:
- Mobility (whether or not an electric outlet is required, size)
- Noise (for example, being able to pump while you’re on the phone)
- Usability (features like timers, settings)
- Price
What Are the Pros to Getting a Spectra Breast Pump?
The majority of Spectra customers are very satisfied with their pump.
Comfort, noise level, and customer service were cited by users in the Facebook group as the three main benefits of Spectra pumps.
1. Comfort
The fact that the Spectra pump was much gentler than other pumps they had used was cited as one of the things users liked best about it.
“I liked it much better compared to my Pump in Style because it was kinder to my nipples,” said Lisa, who made use of S1.
2. Pump Noise (or Lack Thereof)
According to the Spectra website, the pumps have a noise level between a computer and a refrigerator at about 45 decibels.
Cari, a Spectra S2 user, said, “Nobody knew when I used it during business conference calls.”
3. Customer Service
All of the people I spoke with praised Spectra’s customer service for being incredibly responsive and helpful.
“When my pump lost suction, they overnighted me new tubing and a new pump. They said compare both and decide which I wanted to keep,” said Cari.
Are There Any Cons to Spectra Breast Pumps?
Comparatively speaking to some of the other pumps on the market, these two pumps are a little heavier and less portable. The Freestyle Flex or the Willow are examples of those smaller pumps; however, their prices are frequently much higher.
The only other thing I would add is that, depending on where you live, it might be difficult to run to the store in a pinch and buy replacement parts (if yours break or you lose a piece). To avoid problems with this, you might want to buy extra parts in bulk.
Who Should Get the Spectra S1?
The Spectra S1 is quiet and unobtrusive for a gentle pumping experience, making it ideal for busy moms. It is also portable and quickly rechargeable. The Spectra S1 plus can also function as a single or double pump, which saves a ton of time.
Who Should Get the Spectra S2?
The Spectra S2 pump is the best option for first-time mothers with a low milk supply. It is kinder to women who have never pumped, according to moms.
Less than three pounds make it lightweight, portable, and it has a variety of cycle setting options. A double electric breast pump is another feature of the Spectra S2 plus.
Should I Get a Spectra S1 Or S2?
A rechargeable battery makes life so much simpler, especially if you only pump or need to move around while you do it. So, if your budget permits, I’d strongly advise going with the S1.
Check to see if there is an upgrade option available if your insurance only covers an S2. Some insurance providers provide free basic pumps as part of insurance coverage and the option to cover the cost of an upgraded pump.
Please feel free to share your thoughts about the Spectra pumps in the comments if you have used any of them.
Spectra Breast Pump S1 Vs. S2 – FAQ & Pumping Tips
If you’re still undecided regarding Spectra 1 vs. 2, learning more about these breast pumps may help you make the right decision.
Can I Charge the S1 Or S2 in the Car?
You can use a 12V car lighter adapter to charge the Spectra S1 and S2 in your car. Keep in mind that they cannot be charged with an adapter created before February 2015.
What is the Best Pumping Bra for Spectra?
The flanges on the Spectra S1 and S2 breast pumps are unusually large compared to those on other electric breast pumps. Additionally, the breast shield and bottle connector on the Spectra are one piece and cannot be detached (unlike, for instance, Medela).
Spectra flanges are too large for the cup holes in many pumping bras due to their distinctive design.
With Spectra, you can still enjoy hands-free pumping; all you need is a good bra with more supportive cups and bigger holes.
The best Spectra pumping bra is this Kindred Bravely Sublime. Even for bustier mothers, it provides complete coverage and good separation. Nothing sticks or irritates your skin because of seamless design. And it’s sturdy enough to support milk bottles and Spectra flanges.
Why is the Spectra S1 More Expensive?
The Spectra S1 costs more than the Spectra S1 model because it has a rechargeable battery. Without being tethered to an electrical outlet, you can use this pump anywhere.
How Long Does the S1 Or S2 Take to Charge?
After three hours of use, the Spectra S1 and S2 only require two to three hours of plugged-in time.
Which Spectra Model is the Best?
Which Spectra breast pump is best will largely depend on your preferences and way of life. Here are some advice I have for picking the ideal Spectra model for YOU.
- If you want a hospital-grade breast pump that is also portable, the Spectra S1 Plus is the best option. The best Spectra model is available for moms who solely pump and are on a tight budget. It’s also a fantastic option for mothers who are back at work and want to continue feeding their children breast milk.
- The Spectra S2 Plus is the best choice for mothers with limited resources who require a double electric breast pump and don’t mind constantly using an AC adapter. Stay-at-home mothers can benefit from this solution.
- For mothers who only occasionally want to pump milk or require a compact and portable breast pump for travel, the Spectra S9 Plus is the best option.
- The most expensive breast pump made by Spectra is called the Synergy Gold. For mothers who exclusively pump and have a more flexible budget, it is a great option because it has separate adjustments for each breast.
Is Spectra Better Than Medela?
Spectra is preferred by many mothers over the well-liked Medela breast pumps. Both the Spectra S1 and S2 electric breast pumps are more powerful than the Medela Freestyle or Medela Pump In Style and provide better adjustments that could be useful if you have trouble producing enough milk.
When we contrast Spectra with Medela Symphony, Spectra appears to be a better option because it is much more portable and costs a fraction of what Symphony does.
Is the Spectra S1 Hospital Grade?
Both the Spectra S1 and S2 are breast pumps made for hospitals. With its high-quality, closed system that prevents milk backflow, this electric breast pump can be used to drain both breasts simultaneously. In this way, contamination is avoided, making it more hygienic for new mothers and their infants.
This also implies that it is secure for use by numerous users. One of the best breast pumps for low milk supply is Spectra, which can start and support your milk supply.
Its motor lasts a very long time and is strong enough to be used exclusively or frequently for pumping. It’s also quite portable, lightweight, and easy to use.
By the way, according to the FDA there is no official term “hospital grade breast pump”. Breast pumps that are marketed as being of “hospital grade” are frequently made for multiple users and feature an enclosed system to prevent contamination.
Spectra is found to be just as (or even more!) effective when compared to hospital breast pumps.) efficient, strong and well-built.
Does Insurance Cover Spectra S1 and S2?
Insurance providers are now required to pay for a breast pump for nursing mothers, but since each provider has a different plan, some breast pumps are not covered at all or are only partially covered.
Fortunately, your insurance will cover Spectra S2.
On the other hand, the insurance typically only pays a portion of the Spectra S1 cost. Rechargeable batteries in this upgraded model might not be covered by insurance, so you might be on the hook for the cost.
To find out more about getting Spectra through insurance, be sure to get in touch with your insurance provider.
